fbpx

The Free Financial Advisor

You are here: Home / Archives for Investing

3 Easy Steps to Increasing Investment Returns

by 39 Comments

Hello Free Financial Advisor readers! I’m Marvin from Brick By Brick Investing, a blog that focuses on teaching the average joe how to invest in the stock market and grow their wealth in order to achieve financial independence. It’s my pleasure to have you as my audience today. If I could explain one thing to investors it would be this…

Investment returns are not the number one factor in regards to building wealth through the stock market. Now before you strike me down and start to curse my name hear me out. I pride myself in being completely honest with you and if our roles were reversed I would want you to do the same. Here are the three things that you have complete control over that matter most.

 

Earn More Money

 

While some make the noble attempt to educate themselves financially it has been my experience that they prematurely start investing and in return lose a substantial amount of money. I would advise instead of focusing all that energy chasing hot stock tips, attempt to be the best in your field. Strive hard for that promotion at work or for that bonus and when you achieve success allocate your increase in income to your overall portfolio. I would much rather see a safe low risk return of 6-8% on a portfolio of $100k+ than a high risk return of 15-20% on a portfolio of $10k.

Throughout college I worked hard and was able to levy that hard work into a favorable job market where I obtained a very coveted job skill. In return I was able to start making a large sum of money compared to my peers that I graduated with the year before. It wasn’t easy, there was a lot of sacrifice not only from myself but from my family as well. I basically sacrificed three years of my young adult life in order to acquire a nice salary. Now I am able to make low risk trades and investments and compound my wealth.

 

Increase Your Savings Rate

 

Stop trying to keep up with Joneses and stop living above your means. Eliminate your debt and spend less than you earn while investing the rest. I believe a good bit of us have been deployed and lived under basic conditions. Therefore I believe it is safe to say you can do without some of the luxuries that deplete cash from your wallet. I personally recommend that individuals should strive to save 50% of their income AFTER tax.

Time and time again I hear that this cannot be done but I did it for two years of my life. In fact I use to save 80% of my after tax income before I got married. I will never forget the day my wife discovered that I used shirts on hangers as curtains for my room, her facial expression was priceless. For six months I had nothing more than a mattress, laptop, and gorilla case in my room. These are the things that allowed me to save so much money at a young age. Since then my wife and I have come to happy medium and we save 50% of our after tax income and indulge in some luxuries but if it were up to me we could save a lot more.

 

Choose A Great Financial Advisor

 

While no fault of their own a lot of individuals believe all financial advisors are created equal, but the harsh reality is they are not. It is imperative that you verify potential advisors credentials, fee structure, and capabilities. Some advisors may try to use a broad stroke with all their clients and you need to verify that your potential advisor has a plan for your specific situation. Do not feel that you cannot ask questions. In fact you are interviewing them for a job to manage your investments. Ensure that you leave no questions unasked and make sure you understand the answers that are given to you. Albert Einstein said, “If you can’t explain it simply, then you don’t know it well enough.”

 

Increasing Investment Returns Can Be Simple

 

If you do these three things I guarantee you will outperform 90% of your peers in terms of investing and ensure a successful retirement. These are the things I live, preach, and teach.

Photo: Tony Crider

Enhanced by Zemanta

Bad Advice? Here’s Some From Top Money Gurus

by 49 Comments

Don’t let experts paint your future with a broad brush. Reach down to understand where you disagree, then latch on to the rest.

 

Early in my career I made a horrible mistake: I disagreed with Suze Orman’s advice in a discussion with a potential client. Guess what I found out? I don’t have a big enough megaphone to win that argument. The potential client went away. I learned not to fight with Suze, even if she isn’t in the room.

Now, however, as a slightly more mature (and infinitely more handsome) individual investor, I’ve learned that it’s okay to disagree. It takes an understanding of the guru’s overall approach to reaffirm the other 95% you agree with. I’ve realized that Suze Orman, as much as I dislike the finger pointing and incredibly ego-driven persona, is a credit to the financial community (did I just write that?). Experts like Suze and those below speak to a wide audience so they have to use broad terms.

Sometimes I just think the brush is a little too wide.

 

5 Topics Where “Experts” Get It Wrong

 

Liz should be writing "I'm a little off on the "Risk" chapter of this book."

Liz should be writing “I’m a little off on the “Risk” chapter of this book.”

5) Liz Weston – Don’t Avoid Risk, Embrace It. While Liz Weston is far from controversial, I’m not a fan of the way she presents risk. She says that to be an investor, you can’t be afraid. You must have some risk in your portfolio to reach results.

In short, if you want it, you need to gamble a little.

Being afraid is a good thing. Fear motivates. What are you afraid of? Here’s what you should be afraid of

…that you won’t reach your goal

…that you’ll leave your family destitute

…that you’ll become disabled and be unable to care for yourself or anyone else.

This fear helps you look closely at all the risk, not just stock market volatility. Afraid of losing money? Try sticking it in a CD for 30 years and see what it buys. Afraid of flushing your money down the toilet? Pay off that loan at 3% (before the itemized tax deduction) instead of keeping up with inflation. While I understand the sentiment, you owe it to yourself to get ahead, not bust your ass paddling like a salmon against the current.

 

4) David Chilton – Budgets are a myth. I enjoy the book the Wealthy Barber, and love the message in Chilton’s smackdown on budgets: budgets create frustration, because it’s so difficult to adhere to one. The key instead, is to focus on saving money. If you have an emergency fund and know how you spend, you’re more likely to “win” with your financial picture.

While I can see Chilton’s point (probably more than any of the other four I’ve outlined here), there still is a place for budgets. By attempting to stick to a budget and knowing ahead of time that it won’t always work, you’re a step ahead of those who just don’t budget at all. You need to know where you spend your cash.

theFreeFinancialAdvisor.com Financial Gurus Bad Advice

You don’t need an advisor! Just buy all forty of my books….

3) Suze Orman – You Don’t Need an Advisor. Suze’s main premise here is spot on: nobody knows your money like you do, and nobody will care as much as you do. That’s 100% true. I couldn’t care about my client’s money emotionally. In fact, my clients would have fired me if I’d been making emotional decisions with their cash.

Here’s the difference between Suze and I: I live in the real world.

I practiced financial planning for some of the brightest minds in the metro Detroit area. These people could financial plan their lives on their own. So, if I don’t care as much as they do, why did smart people hire me?

Simple. I disagreed with them and broadened their horizons.

How many CEOs don’t have advisors? How many heads of state don’t have advisors? If you’re looking to get ahead, decide when the right time is to add an advisor to your team, and then make sure you pick a good one. I think we spend too much time clustering the whole financial world into one big ball of money-grubbing rotten advisors. Keep that approach and you’ll find yourself starved for time and falling behind the people who decided to find top notch help.

 

2) Dave Ramsey – Debt Snowball. Okay….first, I know that Ramsey’s method was recently commended for working more often because people are emotional beings and pay down debt more quickly when they set smaller milestones. I get it.

What I don’t get is why people don’t ask themselves the question, “How do I do this faster?” What if you could have use the portion of the debt snowball plan that works–the psychological part–but combine it with a method that attacks interest payments most quickly (that’s how you’ll save the big bucks).

With options around like Ready For Zero, Payoff, and others, there is no reason to continue using the Debt Snowball method. You can psychologically attack your debt AND eat up those extra interest payments. You’ll laugh your way to the bank.

 

We discuss Dave Ramsey’s fight with the internet over 12% rates of return on our podcast: Two Guys and Your Money, Episode 35: Pat Flynn Lets Go.

 

1) David Bach – The Latte Factor. What idiotic, absolute drivel. I’ve never seen a person become wealthy by avoiding a latte. Sure, maybe there’s a bigger message here, because the poor person who’s drinking an overpriced Starbucks drink is the same person who’s also buying up clothing on credit at Nordstrom. They’re over their head.

Want to become rich? Stop thinking about $4 decisions with 95% of your brain and instead prioritize. If you could make a $150 decision while in a Starbucks, why wouldn’t you? Decide which action pays the highest, avoid complexity, and jump.

No latte or evaluate your insurance? – Evaluate insurance!

No latte or clip coupons? – Clip coupons!

No latte or restructure your portfolio? – Restructure your portfolio!

No latte or find money-saving vacation ideas? – Vacation ideas!

 

Read the “big” books by the financial gurus and understand the REAL message. Weston, Orman, Ramsey, Chilton and (sigh) even Bach all offer good advice…just avoid the bad stuff that sounds good. How do you know which is which? Think!

Photos: Liz Weston: marubozo; Suze Orman: David Shankbone; BucksFee: JellyDude

Where do you disagree with “the Experts” in your financial plan? 

 

Dow Reaches All-Time High: Is Now The Time To Invest?

by 19 Comments

This article could be consider “Part 2” of the article I posted a few weeks ago, Is It Time for the Market to Crash

Write it down: March 5, 2013 the Dow reached it’s all-time high at a close of 14,253.77. Remember the last “all-time” high?  It was in 2007, October to be exact.  The bear market low of 2009?  That was almost exactly four years ago, March 6, 2009.  So the question becomes: Is now the right or wrong time to invest?

First, let’s take a look at where we are.  The markets are up over 100% since the Great Recession, but why?  Isn’t the economy still in shambles here and overseas?  Job growth is anemic, currency and debt issues abound, right?

True.  All true.  But stocks aren’t priced based on what the currency markets are or aren’t doing.  They’re not priced based on the trade balance between Argentina and Botswana.  They’re priced based on expectation of future earnings.  It’s that simple.

Or it’s not.

 

The Case For Now IS The Right Time To Invest

 

There are of course, other factors – for example, stocks have been (and probably will continue to be for a while) a better overall value than bonds and other fixed income securities like CDs.  Interest rates continue to be low and investors are generally tired of their paltry 0.50% interest on their cash in the banks.  Just this week I had a conversation with a client who has $50,000 in cash reserves, earning a whopping 0.75% dividend at his local bank.  Those factors also drive stock prices higher.

We should ask this question: How are the largest companies of the U.S. and the world doing?  Some other questions that will lead you to a rosy future: Look at free cash flow (that’s at an all time high) corporate balance sheets (exceptionally flush with cash) company stock buy-backs (trending higher) dividend payouts (and the ever increasing rate of those payouts).

That mutual fund of yours? Based on these numbers, it appears we’re headed higher.

 

The Case For Now ISN’T The Right Time To Invest

 

That doesn’t mean there won’t be major pullbacks.  A few weeks ago, I talked about having a “It’s time for the market to crash” kit ready to go.  Investors are piling money into the market again after sitting on the sidelines while things looked lousy, and that’s not a good sign.

Just because you’re planning for a pullback doesn’t mean you can’t also be planning for the next leg up.  As I talked about then, planning is important, but plans are not. (So said the wise Winston Churchill…just a few years before I wrote it here).

 

My Overall Take

 

When I evaluate the strength of earnings potential of the greatest companies here and abroad I see great things ahead.  That doesn’t mean there won’t be market swings.  It doesn’t mean there won’t be a pullback of some kind.  But when I look to the future, I see a world that continues to get bigger, faster, and stronger, and I’d rather own the companies that are leading the charge.

So yes, now’s the time to invest.  But so was yesterday and the day before and so it will be tomorrow.  As long as you believe in the future and think tomorrow will be better than today, it’s always a good time to invest. Don’t stop your investment plan because of CNBC hype or Wall Street Journal headlines.

…but, if I’m wrong – and Lord knows I probably will be more times than not – I’ve still got a back up plan on the shelf ready to execute at a moments notice, and you should, too.

Enhanced by Zemanta

How To Increase Your Yield Through Microloans

by 23 Comments

Sometimes it takes a little creativity to reach your destination.

The world economy continues to slowly gain traction but many cash investors aren’t seeing that translate to increased yield in their short and mid-term cash investments.  According to Bankrate.com, the average yield for a $10,000 money market investment was a paltry 0.52%.  That’s a whopping $52 per year, excluding any fees or costs, and definitely excluding inflation.  Last year, the Social Security Administration increased retiree benefits by 1.7% to offset increasing costs.  Based on that inflation adjustment, investors are losing purchasing power each and every year by doing what at first glance appears to be the right thing: investing in a reliable money market account.

Imagine an investment that guarantees you’re going to lose money – that’s what a traditional cash reserve is doing today. That’s why so many bloggers lately question the need for an emergency fund at all. Don’t fall into that trap.

Microloans: A Primer

Microloans are very small loans made to borrowers who typically lack collateral to support the loan.  Sometimes, microloans are also made to those who don’t have steady employment or even verifiable credit.   There are two well-known microloan organizations – serving a completely different market. The most well known peer-to-peer lender is Prosper.com.  They have over 1.6 million customers and have funded over $400 million in loans to their members.  Prosper.com helps connect borrowers who have reasonable credit with lenders who are trying to earn a higher return on their money.  The other micro-lending site is Kiva.  They primarily help people and families across the world to “create opportunity and alleviate poverty.”  Between the two, Kiva seems altruistic, whereas Prosper seems more capitalistic.

How To Earn Money

While both Kiva and Prosper offer the opportunity to lend money to whomever you wish (and for whatever purpose you wish), Prosper created a system to help those who want to use Prosper as an investing tool.  On their website, they breakdown all the financial metrics for the different types of loan ratings.  Prosper also provides advice on how to create a “diversified” portfolio of microloans.  (Diversification is important when investing in loans – some are going to default!)

Returns on these investments are beyond enticing – Prosper’s best members, those they rate AA – have an average credit score of 808 (well above the national average).  Those AA loans have a historical loss rate of 1.70% – but have an average return of 5.50%!  That’s leaps and bounds above our Money Market rate listed above.  The lowest rated Prosper members (credit score 683) have a 14% loss rate and a 13.29% average return.  A well-diversified portfolio of Prosper loans could make an attractive portfolio.

It’s Not All Roses

This may seem like a great “fire-and-forget mission” and in some ways it is, but there are some things you’ll need to recognize before you invest in microloans at a place like Prosper.  First, the loans are three years long, and there’s no way to get your money back early if you truly need it.  Secondly, you will experience some defaults.  As I mentioned above, even the highest rated consumers still default.  You need to realize you’re becoming the bank!  Prosper recognizes that their traditional model doesn’t suit everyone, so they have created their Prosper Trade Notes program, but even that comes with it’s own long list of pros and cons.

Sum It Up

If you have some extra cash reserves – money that you know you aren’t going to use for at least three years – Prosper.com could be a viable solution to increase your yield.  If you want to loan money for a more altruistic purpose, consider Kiva.  Both of them serve a specific purpose, but Prosper has a greater chance to provide a consistent income stream for the investor.

Photo: Philip Taylor PT

5 Great Stock Buying Tips To Practice Today

by 36 Comments

Care enough about your portfolio to practice, practice, practice.

Small investors are a mess. Too many of us want to have a portfolio that looks clean and tidy, but we don’t want to be bothered to practice learning the skills it’ll take. Why not? I just left the Texas High School State Swim Championships, where my kids both swam with the best of the best. Do you know how they got there? Would it surprise you if I told you that it wasn’t walking around saying, “I think I can swim a really fast time this meet?”

Of course it wouldn’t surprise you. People who don’t care don’t read financial blogs, do they? You’re ready to rock!

Since they were 7 years old, my kids have been in the water practicing for this last weekend. Sure, at the time they were just looking to get through the next meet, but because they’re seniors in high school, there’s a big chance that neither will go beyond the speeds they swam in the pool this weekend ever again. All of that work culminated in this last chance at the pool. My daughter swam her fastest time ever and my son swam in 2nd fastest times in all of his 4 events. Practice didn’t make perfect. Perfect practice made perfect. Lots of hours of perfect practice.

 

What does this have to do with stocks?

 

When I see failing investors, it’s often because they want success in the moment. Because anyone can buy a stock, it looks easy, doesn’t it? Who can’t pick the next big winner?

Watching pros trade and then observing Main Street trade you begin to understand the difference. The pro takes a ton more time and care when picking than just asking the dude next to him at work what’s rockin’ for him!

You too can become a better stock picker if you take the time to learn identifiers of a reliable investment. You can pull the trigger on your investments in a better way once you’ve picked the stock.

 

5 stock buying tips to practice today to become a better investor:

 

1)   Practice comparing stocks in a category and read the annual report. I actually love to read the message at the beginning of annual reports. Why? I get a feeling for the business and their focus. You’ll learn who the competitors are, what the product does, and what their concerns are.

Several years ago I happened to be reading the annual reports of GE and a casino back-to-back. Jack Welch, then CEO of GE, wrote about how the company needed to improve on all fronts. He wrote about how empowering their workforce was the #1 goal of the company. He also wrote that someone asked him about the end customer, and why that wasn’t his focus. He said that if he focused on his people, they’d do a better job with customers, and everyone would win. The casino? They talked about the current economic climate and how it was difficult to do anything when people weren’t gambling. They focused on regulatory changes and travel costs. Guess which one won my hard earned money that day?

Don’t stop at the fluff messages written by PR people, though. Take one statistic each week and become familiar with it. Start with PE ratio, then Price-to-Book. Learn to compare revenue and earnings numbers. Dive into insider trades (not the illegal variety…stick with watching what the “big wigs” at the company are purchasing).

2)   Learn to make watch lists, and watch them.  When I created my first watch lists, they were WAY too long and unorganized. I learned through my experience, though. Good stock picking is about creating crude systems and then working your system to improve.

3)   Buy stocks at the market, and avoid the open. How egotistical is it to think that a stock that’s been rocketing (those are the ones you should focus on, by the way), will turn around and reverse course just long enough to descend to YOUR CHOSEN SPOT and then turn around again and shoot to the moon? How omniscient do you think you are?

A key part in realizing the danger of the market is in knowing that you are a little itty-bitty part of a much bigger financial market that you cannot possibly understand. As much as CNBC and Fox Business try to tell you “why” the stock market moved, they have no clue. If you understand that you have no idea where the market is going to go tomorrow you’ll do two things better: 1) you’ll buy stocks you really like on an up-trend, and 2) you’ll pay a hell of a lot more attention to your downside risk.

4)   Buy an option. One time, write a covered call. We’ve written about how these work already. If you haven’t done it yet, what are you waiting for? Sure, you may lose a dollar or two, but what’s the price of education? You’ll never know how it works REALLY until you REALLY do it. Jump in and sell a covered call. It’s the least risky option available.

5)   When you screw up (and you will), don’t think “I’m never doing that again.” Sadly, that’s the message most investors receive when markets turn against them. This is the market teaching you a lesson! Use the lesson! Don’t go off and mess up some other area where you’re clueless!

Photo: Jim Bahn

What “Golden Rules” do you practice when investing outside of “buy and hold?” Put your 5 Stock Buying Tips out there so others can learn!

5 Smart Money Moves For Young Families

by 18 Comments

Even a small step in the right direction counts. The best Valentine’s gift for young families? Getting on the same page.

As a Certified Financial Planner™ practitioner, I meet with clients from all walks of life.  One of the things I say to all my clients is, “I’m never too busy to meet with anyone you’d recommend.”  Which, of course, is a nice way of saying – “l’ll meet with anyone as a favor to you.”

Usually clients have a pretty good idea who we’re after from a prospecting standpoint, but on occasion, I am asked to meet with a client’s grandson or nephew – someone who may not be in our “target audience” as it relates to practice growth.

But, I’ll always gladly help them.

 

Why I’m Telling You This Story

 

Last week, I had the privilege of meeting with a young couple – Jack and his lovely spouse…Jill.  (We’ll change the names to protect the innocent).  They were the typical American young family – just out of college, a young child, tons of college debt, a handful of credit card debt, no real savings, and a meager job just to pay the rent.  They looked like deer in the headlights when they walked into my office.

I know the type – I used to be Jack and maybe you were (or are) too – young, arrogant, (heck, I’m still that one), confused, unsure of oneself – so much unknown, you don’t know even where to start.  That was Jack and Jill, except they wanted help, but they had no idea where to start.

And frankly, hiring our firm wouldn’t help them that much either, and I told them as much.  They looked exasperated – I could see it on their faces – “if this guy can’t help, we’re doomed.”  So we sat down and started making a list of all the small things – things you can do with under $1,000 – to get the ball rolling in your financial and personal life.  I’m narrowing them down to my top 5:

 

Build a portfolio early

 

If you search around, you can find a nice discount broker who won’t rob you in commissions, and then buy two exchange traded funds (ETFs): one which tracks the S&P 500 and another that follows a bond index.  For example, 5 shares of SPY or IVV (S&P 500 funds) and 2 shares of AGG (Aggregate Bond Index) will give you a 70% equity / 30% fixed income portfolio.  That’s quite a start.

I explained to Jack and Jill that if they start early, a little guy called “gains” can work in their favor. Make your money work for you as quickly as possible and you’re reap huge rewards down the road.

 

Pay attention to tax shelters

 

If you need the money, save it into a spot where you can get it. But taxes can drain from your returns, so if possible, shelter the funds.

Small steps…investing even $1,000 in a Roth IRA and adding $100 a month from age 22 to 65 would turn into $478,000!  As we’ve mentioned several times, you can access your contribution at any time so it could double as a little cash reserve if you need the money.

There’s also good news at the end of this tunnel: in most families, they’re able to contribute more later as they earn more cash. Set a good foundation with small amounts today and

 

Cash is the key to your debt repayment

 

I’ve seen too many people attack debt with every dollar, only to find the dishwasher broken or the muffler dragging behind the car. Where do you go for cash then if you’ve drained all of your funds?

Right back into debt.

Don’t start the habit of pulling plastic out of your wallet. It gets easier and easier every time you do it. Keep a cash reserve. By cash, I mean cash. With our increased reliance on ATM machines, credit cards, etc., a simple power outage can cause quite the disruption.  Live through the next Zombie apocalypse by keeping $500 or $1,000 in cash at home in a safe.  But remember, this is for emergency only! I’ve met too many new investors who spend their emergency funds on vacations or credit card repayment. That’s not why that money’s there.

Speaking of emergencies…with a young family, don’t forget insurances. I told Jack and Jill to focus on disability insurance at work and cheap term life insurance.

 

Manage your energy

 

Huh?  Are you talking about vacation?  Jack and Jill can’t afford anything! Are you nuts?

They thought I was crazy at first, but like I’ve said…I’ve been there before. Let me explain. When you’re buried in debt, the last thing you need is an expensive, week long trip. But you need to keep a clear head to move the ball forward, so take smaller vacations…but still take some!

These vacations aren’t because you deserve them. You don’t. They won’t help your debt in a direct way. But indirectly? You’ll notice a huge difference in your ability to attack your problems when you’re fresh and relaxed.

Find a deal to hop the train to Toronto or Chicago for the weekend if you’re in the Midwest, or Austin if you’re in Texas.  Use a travel site like Hotels.com to book your reservation and save money.  Take a quick cruise to the Bahamas.  Remeber to do whatever it takes to keep away the cobwebs and return fresh. It doesn’t need to be expensive…it just has to be “away.”

Recent studies have shown a direct correlation between physical health and monetary wealth (unintended rhyme…happy Valentine’s Day!) If you’re lucky enough to have short commute – try a different method for a week and see how you feel.  Could you walk?  Ride a bike?  Adding a little cardio exercise to your day will make you feel better and will improve your work attitude and output.  Give it a try –if you rode your bike to work only 3 days a week and it was 5 miles each way, you’d ride 1,500 miles a year!

 

Educate your children

 

I told Jack and Jill that this was the most frustrating part of my job: meeting too many new investors who had no idea what moves to make first. Stop the cycle by helping your kids become money-savvy. Most people think I’m going to say, “Invest in a 529 plan.”  Wrong.  IF you do invest in a 529 plan, teach them to track the funds with you. Play board games that help them think about strategy and money. Let them sit in on your budget meetings. Track electrical output in your house and make it a game. Heck, invest in a Kindle from Amazon.  They’re $150 or so, and if they’re young enough, sign them up for Amazon Free Time, (a service that pre-screens kid-approved content for one low monthly cost of $3). Don’t leave them alone with the stuff and expect your kids to learn. Make it family time with the Kindle, or heck, with a book. Remember those?

Recent studies have shown a direct correlation between physical health and monetary wealth (unintended rhyme…happy Valentine’s Day!) If you’re lucky enough to have short commute – try a different method for a week and see how you feel.  Could you walk?  Ride a bike?  Adding a little cardio exercise to your day will make you feel better and will improve your work attitude and output.  Give it a try –if you rode your bike to work only 3 days a week and it was 5 miles each way, you’d ride 1,500 miles a year!

 

Bonus:  Communicate

The closest we’ll get to a good Valentine’s gift today is this: communicate. Especially communicate if you’re worried, but also when things are going well. Practice our weekly meeting plan. Real budgets are about keeping the family on the same page, not about dollars on a spreadsheet. Especially in married or cohabitating couples, I find that one generally knows what’s going on with the money while the other is in Fantasyland. Don’t make this mistake. When you both own your financial life,

Jack and Jill left looking relieved. They didn’t have to hire an expensive financial advisor and had a pretty clear road map on how to start down the road to prosperity.

 

Who delivered your first financial lesson?

Holiday Games and Finance: What Can the Game “Dominion” Teach You About Money?

by 22 Comments

While Joe’s playing Dominion with his sister, brother in law and spouse (we all l.o.v.e. this game at our house), Erin Shanendoah of The Dog Ate My Wallet fame holds down the fort at the blog. Hope you’re enjoying some quality family time like we are!

Dominion is hands down the favorite game in our house. Set up is minimal, and you can get through a 2 player game in as little as 10 minutes if both the players know the cards. Every game is different, which means that players need to be open to different kinds of strategies if they want a chance at winning.

Even forgetting that you have money within the game (copper, silver, gold & platinum(in the expansions)), you can learn a lot about finances from Dominion.

Every game is different. Just like every person’s financial situation is different. Because of this, there is no one strategy works for every game of Dominion, and there is no one size fits all solution to personal finance. You have to look at the cards that have been  dealt and figure out the best plan for this game, this situation. Only by responding to the uniqueness of each situation can you hope to consistently do well.

Multiple strategies can be viable options. My husband and roommate both love playing games, and for the most play well together. But they have different outlooks on life and will often see the exact same set of cards and come up with two completely different ways to win. They each go with the strategy that they are the most comfortable with.

Just because someone has a similar financial situation to you does not mean you have to both take the same financial strategy. Find what works for you and what you’re comfortable with, and you’ll have a much greater chance of “winning”.

Diversity is good. Too much is not. Currently, there is the base set and 7 expansions for Dominion. While you can play with as many expansions as you want, we’ve found the best games are limited to 3 sets- usually the base plus two expansions. 3 sets gives you lots of options, but you don’t lose the synergy between cards.

Diversifying your holdings financially helps mitigate your risk, but if you diversify too much, you lose the power of “buying in bulk” so to speak. (Average Joe and The Other Guy can both speak about this much more eloquently than me.)

Sometimes you just need more money. Other times, you need your money to work harder for you. Within Dominion, you use money to buy other cards. You can buy more money, action cards, or victory point cards. Sometimes, the best strategy is to use your money to buy more money, especially in the early stages of the game. But later, you’ll want to use that money to buy action cards. Those cards allow you to advance your strategy, hinder the strategy of others, and sometimes even buy the highest value victory card, even though you started the hand with only 2 coppers.

Early on in your life, often the best solution to money problems is just to get more–go out and work a second job, find a way to earn passive income, etc. But once you get to the point where you’re not struggling to pay the bills, you need your money to work for you. By making smart moves with your money, you can open new doors for yourself or your family, and eventually “win” the game by having a comfortable retirement. (I do hope that in real life, you won’t use your money to hinder others. That should be a game strategy only.)

Just sitting on money can slow you down. One might think the one strategy in Dominion that would work in every game would be to use your money to buy more money until you had enough to buy victory cards, and just keep doing that. It doesn’t work. While you obviously need victory cards to win the game, they don’t do anything else. You can’t spend them. You can’t take an action from them (well, in some expansions there are victory cards that have actions, but those are very special cases). Instead, they just take up valuable space in your hand and do nothing, slowing you down.

While sometimes it seems the safest way to save money is just to stick it in the recliner and sit on it, your money can’t grow that way. It can’t actually do anything for you. It’s a strategy that just slows you down.

The cards aren’t always your friends. There are good cards and bad cards in Dominion. There are cards that are good for the person who plays them and awful for others. There are thieve and militias, there are curses and witches. You can be forced to destroy your victory point cards or have a platinum stolen by the player to your left. Sometimes, you just get negative victory points. In order to win, you have to have a strategy to weather or eliminate the bad.

Bad things happen in real life. You need to have the tools to survive them. Sometimes it’s just in making smart decisions and protecting yourself. Getting yourself out of debt and carrying the right kinds and amounts of insurance can also protect you against the vagaries of the world.

Luck always plays a role, but it’s not everything. Because every player of every game of Dominion starts out with the exact same 10 cards, and a five card hand, there’s a limited number of opening hands you can have. But which one you get and how well it works for that particular game, is all a matter of luck. If two good strategies are going against each other, it’s really just going to be luck that decides the winner of the game. But it’s very rare for a well thought out strategy to lose to no strategy at all. Just depending on luck isn’t likely to win the game.

Some people start life luckier than others. Some people get lucky later on. And some people make their own luck by coming up with a well thought out strategy. And in life, it’s not really going to matter if you retire with $2 million while your buddy is ending with $2.1 million. You’ve both “won”.

Don’t forget to have fun. Dominion is a game. The husband and roommate are both competitive people and love to win. I care much more about enjoying the game. But I can’t enjoy the game if I feel ineffective. I will enjoy myself just as much putting together a strategy that comes “this close” to winning as I will winning the game. I will even enjoy a failed strategy if I find a single good combination within it.

How much money you die with matters only to the people you leave it too. You can’t use it anymore. Don’t put your life on hold just to reach some arbitrary savings goal. If you never take vacation until you’re 75 years old, are you going to be able to climb the island stairs at Tintagel? Yes, you want to save for the future and make sure you have enough to retire in comfort, but there’s no counting up victory cards at the end of your life, declaring you the “winner”, so make sure you have some fun along the way.